Hi John,
I'm sorry to hear of your misfortune.
I've checked you numbers & they sound like they COULD be ok. I have stressed could here because ( as usual in life ) nothing is black & white.
I'll present some Info first & then try to show how it could be correct.
OK, the numbers you have given us are great. enough to identify a watch.
I'll go through your points & provide some links to internet sites backing the Info up. ( or quote books )
. According to various tables this would be a movement that was made APPROXIMATLEY in 1972.
Again backed up by one of Chuck's web pages Roman/Chucks Speedmaster movement dates.
HOWEVER !! The Omega Saga Book dates 31,xxx,xxx movements as 1969.
So, as you can see there is no 100% certain way of dating the movement... BUT see below....
There are other sources of backing up this info ( various books etc ), I have just chosen various pages from Chuck's Internet site to "prove" the numbers/features of the watch.
So, up till now, we've shown that the numbers all match within a couple of years.
The late 60's / early 70's was a time of constant changes for the speedmaster, with Omega trying cash in on the "Moon"/"NASA" publicity. there are examples of watches that left the factory using whatever parts were to hand. It is possible that your case was made in '69 & finally got fitted with a movement/bracelet in '71 or '72.
Is it also possible that the movement was swapped early on in the watches life ?
If the watch was sold in/after '72 it is VERY likely (almost certain) that the bracelet endpieces would be marked 633 ( & the bracelet is an 1171 ). Or could it be that the original bracelet broke & was swapped for a more modern version ?
From the info that you have provided, your watch sounds to be genuine. ( I wouldn't bet on it being a fake ) It's obviously difficult to be 100% certain without ever having seen the watch or pictures of it. But usually a fake doesn't have a correct ( or even close to correct ) movement number/markings. You have convinced me that the markings/numbers are from a genuine watch.
Finally, Omega will provide certain information for vintage watches. If I were you, I'd write to them & ask if they can help.
One of the services that Omega provide is to provide a "Certificate of Authenticity". Bascially you provide Omega with the numbers that you listed in you post ( & above ) and IF these match exactly their records, they will send you a Certificate ( I think it costs 50 Swiss francs ). I'm sure this will convince any insurance firm that the watch was genuine. Omega may not want to provide you any Info over the phone / per E-mail, but if you order a Certificate, the Info is on there.
Included in the Info that Omega provide on this certificate is the date the watch was shipped to the Omega dealer & to which country it was sent.
If, for any reason, any of the numbers don't match, Omega simply state that they cannot issue the certificate ( eg the movement was swapped at some stage ).
Feel free to E-mail me or repost here if you need more info /help
I hope this helps.
Steve